Sunday, December 6, 2015

Productive Struggle [part 1]

I want to know more about "Productive Struggle".

Let me be more specific:
If students are allowed to reasonably struggle with a math task, I want to know more about a teacher prescription of actionable steps to:
  • move the learning forward and 
  • avoid a meltdown level of frustration
I built a Productive Struggle Desmos Activity if you would like to share your thoughts and learn from others interested in this topic.

Robert Kaplinksy recently gave a wonderful Ignite Talk on Productive Struggle. Communication was a big part Robert's message. I want to think more (in part 2) about communication as one of the actionable steps in that prescription.

Struggle,
1128

Part 2 is here.

7 comments:

  1. Andrew, that desmos activity is absolutely fantastic. It is simple, it is enlightening, it is a wonderfully creative and inspiring use of the (rapidly evolving!) activity builder format. Well done.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Bryan. I'll post the Overlay of everyone's graphs in Part 2.

      Delete
  2. I'm curious also what peoples' graphs will tend to look like and if patterns will emerge over time.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Strong questions. Looking forward to others' responses.

    ReplyDelete
  4. So your hope is that students will reflect on the relationship between struggle and frustration? I like that because I can see how they would get conflated. So then they could use this activity as a conversation starter? Maybe show various graphs and talk about what they mean?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great ideas. I think it's a way to start the communication I'll be referring to in Part 2.

      Delete
  5. Wondering if/how you could integrate perseverance here Andrew. Does a high level of one or the other negatively or positively affect student productivity? Where is the perseverance "sweet spot"? Both frustration and struggle play a pivotal part in perseverance but how much of each?

    ReplyDelete